Which Is Better: Manual or Automatic Transmissions?



Which Is Better: Manual or Automatic Transmissions?

If you are purchasing a car, one of the most important specifications you look at is the transmission system. The car has either a manual transmission or an automatic transmission. If you have very little knowledge about the car, it is more likely you don’t know which is better. To make things easy for you we have explained the differences between two that will help you make the right choice. 

Understanding the Difference between Manual and Automatic Transmissions

The manual transmission can be easily identified by the gear shifter. Cars with manual transmissions have a gearbox and a clutch pedal. You need to move gear shifter to shift to a lower or higher gear. To change the gear, you need to remove your foot from the accelerator pedal and press the clutch pedal while changing the gear.

In an automatic transmission, the car does not have a clutch pedal or a gearbox. It has bell housing where the engine connects to the transmission. The bell housing has a torque converter. The transmission system also includes planetary gears which provide different gear ratio. When driving a car with automatic transmission, you just have to accelerate or decelerate and the automatic transmission selects the right gear ratio as per road conditions and speed of the vehicle. 

What Are the Advantages of A Manual Transmission?

  • A manual transmission system gives you full control over the vehicle. As the speed of the vehicle increases, you shift to higher gears. If you need more power from the engine, you shift down to a lower gear. 

  • With a manual transmission, you feel more connected to the engine and the vehicle. This enhances the driving experience and you have a certain amount of satisfaction.

  • The manual transmission is system is lighter as it has fewer components. This reduces the weight of the vehicle and in turn, increases gas mileage. 

What Are the Advantages of Automatic Transmissions? 

  • The automatic transmission offers more convenience. When driving a car with automatic transmission, you don’t have to worry about changing gears or pressing clutch pedal every time when changing gears. This helps you concentrate more on the road and enjoy driving.

  • With an automatic transmission, the gear shift is smooth and quick as there are no mechanical gears involved. Driving a car with an automatic transmission is a lot easier in slow-moving or start-stop traffic.

  • Since there are no mechanical gears, there is less probability of gears failing due to wear and tear or mechanical failure.

Which Transmission System Is Good for Fuel Economy? 

  • A manual transmission system has fewer parts and hence the overall weight of the car decreases, thereby increasing fuel economy.

  • An automatic transmission system is enclosed in a cast-iron case whereas a manual transmission system is enclosed in an aluminum case which is comparatively lighter.

Which Transmission System Is Right for You? 

Automatic and manual transmission systems have their pros and cons and there is no clear winner in this comparison. The right transmission system depends on your driving style. If you are looking for convenience, an automatic transmission is good for you. If you want more control over the vehicle while driving, the manual transmission is a way to go.


Tags: